Muslim World Report

Is AI Eroding Human Intelligence in Education?

Dr. Anthony Lindsay | Apr 20, 2025 9:03 AM | 6 min read | 1224 words

TL;DR: The integration of AI tools in education, while offering remarkable opportunities for personalized learning, raises serious concerns about the erosion of critical thinking skills and the potential for misinformation. We need to balance AI usage with essential human educational values to avoid creating a generation lacking in intellectual depth.

AI and Education: A Double-Edged Sword

The Situation

The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies, particularly tools like ChatGPT, has ignited a fervent debate within educational and intellectual circles. Proponents hail AI as a revolutionary force that can enrich learning experiences and broaden access to knowledge. Conversely, critics warn that these technologies threaten human intelligence, undermining the very foundations of education and critical thought. This discourse is vital as it shapes not only individual learning trajectories but also societal structures worldwide.

Concerns Raised

  • Increasing Reliance on Technology: Students are turning to AI for quick answers, bypassing essential processes like:
    • Research
    • Analysis
    • Synthesis of information

This trend raises concerns about a generation adept at using technology but lacking critical thinking and complex problem-solving skills (İsmail Çelik, 2022; Nitin Liladhar Rane et al., 2023).

  • Proliferation of Misinformation: The rise of misinformation, exacerbated by social media, complicates this landscape. AI can disseminate incorrect or biased information, skewing public understanding of key issues (Jon Roozenbeek et al., 2020).

Global Implications

As nations contend with AI challenges:

  • Widening Educational Disparities: Countries with strong technological infrastructures may benefit from AI-enhanced education, while those with fewer resources could fall further behind, widening the digital divide (Ammar Abulibdeh et al., 2024).
  • Socioeconomic Disconnect: The disconnect between social classes influences the quality of education, especially among marginalized groups in developing regions (Siew Ping Han & Ben Kumwenda, 2024; Cedric Bheki Mpungose, 2020).

Given this context, we must reexamine what constitutes a well-rounded education in the age of AI. Should it merely focus on fact acquisition, or should it also involve critical thinking, analysis, and independent inquiry? Historical discussions remind us that educational reforms often aim to equip learners with skills necessary for navigating complex societal challenges (Alan Collins & Richard Halverson, 2010). If left unaddressed, these questions could have lasting consequences on both personal development and society’s ability to tackle shared challenges.

As we navigate these complexities surrounding AI in education, an urgent dialogue is needed—one that critiques AI’s role but also explores how we can harness these tools to enhance human intelligence rather than diminish it.

What if AI Becomes the Primary Tool for Learning?

If AI tools like ChatGPT are adopted as primary resources for learning, educational experiences could shift dramatically:

  • Education systems may prioritize:
    • Rote learning
    • Standardized outputs over inquiry-based approaches

This reliance could lead to:

  • Diminished engagement with traditional pedagogical methods
  • A decline in essential research and analytical skills
  • An erosion of intellectual curiosity

Long-term societal implications might include:

  • An inefficient workforce ill-equipped to tackle complex challenges
  • Homogenization of thought, where singular AI outputs shape opinions, threatening innovation and problem-solving (Richard W. Paul & Penelope Heaslip, 1995).

What if AI Empowered Informed Decision-Making?

Conversely, if educational systems integrate AI as supportive learning aids, we could see a significant enhancement in education quality:

  • Personalized Tutoring: AI could guide students through complex subjects, encouraging deeper inquiry.
  • Tailored Resources: By providing timely feedback, AI can bolster learners’ confidence and engagement (Afshan Bibi, 2024).

The implications of this shift could foster:

  • An educated citizenry with advanced analytical skills capable of addressing societal challenges from climate change to political instability (Xuesong Zhai et al., 2021).
  • A culture of continuous learning and innovation, leading to a populace that demands transparency and evidence-based policymaking (Nitin Liladhar Rane et al., 2023).

What if Misinformation Amplified with AI Integration?

The potential for misinformation to proliferate in an AI-enhanced educational landscape poses grave risks:

  • AI tools may generate and disseminate misinformation, muddying public discourse (Gordon Pennycook & David G. Rand, 2021).

If students and educators fail to develop frameworks for discerning credible sources, the consequences may include:

  • A decline in education quality, with graduates holding distorted understandings of critical issues (Amr Jamal et al., 2023).
  • Increased societal polarization as individuals retreat into echo chambers, heightening skepticism towards institutions (Sharda Umanath et al., 2021).

To mitigate these risks, stakeholders must prioritize:

  • Teaching critical thinking alongside AI literacy, emphasizing skepticism and fact-checking (Cecilia Ka Yuk Chan, 2023).

Addressing these issues is essential to prevent an environment where misinformation thrives, leading to societal fragmentation and failure in collective problem-solving.

Structured Analysis of ‘What If’ Scenarios

These potentialities frame the dual-edged nature of AI in education. Each presents unique challenges and opportunities, necessitating a nuanced approach to integrating AI technologies.

  1. Dependency and Deterioration of Skills: Over-reliance on AI tools could lead to diminished independent thought, critical analysis, and creativity. Educational systems must strive for balance, ensuring technology complements foundational educational practices.

  2. Empowerment and Enhanced Learning: Thoughtful AI integration could enrich educational experiences. Educators must blend traditional methods with technology to create robust learning environments.

  3. Misinformation and Critical Literacy: Education must incorporate AI use alongside the development of media literacy and critical thinking skills, enabling students to navigate complex information landscapes successfully.

Strategic Maneuvers

In light of these challenges, stakeholders must develop strategic responses to safeguard learning integrity and human intelligence.

  • Curricula Evolution: Integrate AI literacy as a core component to prepare students for effective use and critical scrutiny of AI-generated information (Gila Kurtz et al., 2024).

  • Educator Development: Equip educators to use AI as a complementary tool, enhancing engagement without supplanting essential teaching practices (Rudra Tiwari, 2023).

  • Policymaker Involvement: Establish frameworks ensuring equitable access to AI technology across socioeconomic divides, supporting investment in infrastructure and resources (Sonia Livingstone, 2003).

  • Student Engagement: Encourage students to shape their learning experiences through feedback mechanisms, fostering accountability and adaptability in educational institutions.

References

  • Abulibdeh, A., Al-Sharif, L., & Khamis, M. (2024). Addressing the Digital Divide in Education: A Policy Framework for AI Integration.
  • Afshan Bibi. (2024). Personalizing Learning Through AI: Opportunities and Challenges.
  • Bheki Mpungose, C. (2020). Bridging the Gap: A Study on Digital Literacy and Marginalized Communities.
  • Çelik, İ. (2022). The Role of AI in Modern Learning Environments.
  • Chan, C. K. Y. (2023). Navigating Misinformation: A Critical Approach to Learning with AI.
  • Collins, A., & Halverson, R. (2010). Rethinking Education in the Age of Technology: The Digital Revolution and Schooling in America.
  • Eden, C. A. (2024). The Impact of AI on Student Engagement in Higher Education.
  • Jamal, A., & aRashid, F. (2023). The Effects of Misinformation on Student Learning Outcomes: A Case Study.
  • Kurtz, G., et al. (2024). AI Literacy in Education: Preparing the Next Generation.
  • Liladhar Rane, N., et al. (2023). A Framework for AI in Education: Balancing Benefits and Risks.
  • Livingstone, S. (2003). The Impact of Digital Technology on Educational Equity.
  • Mpungose, C. B. (2020). Bridging the Divide: The Role of Education and Technology in Developing Countries.
  • Pennycook, G., & Rand, D. G. (2021). Fighting misinformation on social media using crowdsourced judgments of news source quality.
  • Paul, R. W., & Heaslip, P. (1995). A Critical Thinking Framework for Evaluating Information in the Age of Technology.
  • Roozenbeek, J., Schneider, C., et al. (2020). Misinformation and Its Impact on Trust in Institutions.
  • Sharda Umanath, et al. (2021). The Polarizing Effect of Misinformation on Public Discourse: Challenges and Strategies.
  • Tiwari, R. (2023). Enhancing Student Engagement Through AI: A Teacher’s Perspective.
  • Zhai, X., et al. (2021). The Role of Education in Addressing Global Challenges with AI Support.
← Prev Next →