Muslim World Report

Pope Leo XIV Highlights AI's Risks to Dignity and Creativity

Dr. Anthony Lindsay | Jun 20, 2025 10:57 AM | 9 min read | 1896 words

TL;DR: Pope Leo XIV has issued a grave warning about the rapid rise of artificial intelligence (AI) and its threats to human dignity and creativity. Key concerns include:

  • Erosion of Creative Agency: Over-reliance on AI tools diminishes individual creativity and innovation.
  • Economic Disparities: AI’s unchecked growth could exacerbate socio-economic divides and lead to cultural homogenization.
  • Grassroots Movements: There is potential for collective action to demand accountability from tech corporations and advocate for ethical AI practices.

The Pope’s Warning: The Intersection of AI, Dignity, and Global Implications

Pope Leo XIV recently issued a profound warning concerning the rapid ascendance of artificial intelligence (AI) and its implications for human dignity and employment. In a world characterized by remarkable technological advancements, the Pope’s statements resonate deeply within the socio-political fabric of our global society. His caution underscores the deleterious effects of a capitalist framework that prioritizes profit over humanity, reflecting a growing concern about the influence of powerful tech conglomerates consolidating their dominance over the global economy and cultural narratives (Okrah Oppong, 2025).

In the current political landscape, tech magnates such as Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg advocate for stringent AI regulations, citing potential risks associated with its unregulated proliferation. Yet, their focus often remains narrowly tailored to their vested interests, leaving broader societal implications—such as the erosion of creative agency and the existential threat posed to the workforce—sidelined. As AI systems increasingly encroach upon tasks traditionally executed by humans, the consequences for employment are dire, particularly within creative industries where artists and creators face existential risks to their livelihoods (Teo, 2023).

A study indicates that over-reliance on AI tools can diminish individual creativity; participants reported feeling less innovative when leaning on AI, mirroring how dependence on GPS technology can impair navigational skills (Hana, 2023). As creative tasks devolve into mere commands and adjustments, vital problem-solving abilities are bypassed, stifling productivity and risking a collective loss of identity among creators.

The Global Ramifications of AI on Employment and Creativity

The Pope’s warning resonates with a deeper understanding of the global ramifications of AI proliferation. The unchecked development of AI technologies threatens to exacerbate economic disparities as a handful of tech behemoths accumulate immense wealth while millions of workers face potential displacement. This technological upheaval could, in turn, lead to:

  • A steady decline in original art forms
  • A homogenized cultural landscape where diverse narratives are silenced
  • The diminution of human expression (Hofmann, 2021)

Furthermore, the specter of disinformation and propaganda—amplified by AI—undermines essential democratic discourse, fostering societal divisions and engendering mistrust (Kumar Konidena et al., 2024).

In this context, several scenarios emerge, demonstrating the precarious balance between technological advancement and human dignity:

  1. Anti-technocracy Movements: We envision a world where movements rise in response to dissatisfaction with AI’s impact on individual livelihoods, mobilizing to challenge the unchecked power of tech corporations.

  2. Empowerment through AI: What if AI technologies were intentionally utilized as tools for human empowerment? This positive paradigm could lead to a global discourse focused on using AI to augment human capabilities.

Organizations—both governmental and non-governmental—could invest in AI that champions:

  • Creativity
  • Social Justice
  • Economic Equity

By prioritizing ethical considerations in AI development, we can cultivate technology that enhances human potential, supports creators, and uplifts marginalized communities.

Educational institutions hold significant potential in this vision; by integrating AI to enrich learning experiences, students could engage critically with technology while enhancing their intellectual and artistic skills (Wach et al., 2023). Promoting AI as a partner in creativity rather than a substitute could foster a new generation equipped with both technical proficiency and critical thinking.

The Prospective Role of Nations and International Cooperation

International cooperation will play a pivotal role in establishing treaties governing AI usage that align with human rights and labor protections. Such collaborative efforts could yield a more equitable distribution of wealth generated through AI, mitigating the socio-economic divides that plague many societies (Alakwe, 2023).

Furthermore, as we navigate these complex issues, the Muslim community can play an instrumental role in shaping discourse around AI and human dignity. By drawing on Islamic principles of justice, compassion, and communal welfare, Muslim scholars and leaders can initiate dialogues that frame technology as an instrument for enhancing human life rather than undermining it (Pagacz, 2022).

As the global community confronts the implications of AI, we must grapple with the uncertainties of our future. An awareness of the potential for technocratic dominance compels us to devise strategies ensuring that our technological trajectory leads to a more equitable society. The implications of AI for our global society are far-reaching, and it is crucial to consider both potential pitfalls and opportunities presented by this transformative technology.

Economic Disparities and Homogenization of Culture

In contemplating the ramifications of AI’s ascendance, we observe how unchecked technologies exacerbate economic disparities across nations. The same corporations advocating for responsible AI development are also the ones monopolizing technology, often neglecting the socio-economic realities faced by millions. An alarming future could unfold where:

  • Artistic originality and diversity are sacrificed on the altar of efficiency and profit
  • A cultural homogenization stifles marginalized voices and creative expression

The potential fallout of relying on AI to automate creative tasks poses a significant concern. With original art forms at risk of decline, the cultural landscape may evolve into a monotonous tapestry woven from algorithmically-generated content. In this scenario, human creativity risks being relegated to the background, overshadowed by technologies that prioritize profits over authenticity. The urgent question remains: How do we assert control of AI to ensure that it serves humanity, rather than the other way around?

The Role of Grassroots Movements and Community Engagement

The rise of grassroots movements advocating for ethical standards in AI development cannot be understated. As individuals become increasingly aware of the implications of AI technologies on their livelihoods and cultural expressions, a wave of activism could sweep through communities, demanding accountability from both tech corporations and policymakers. But what if these movements are successful? Imagine a world where citizens actively participate in shaping the ethical framework surrounding AI, fostering transparency and inclusivity in technological development.

Such mobilization could lead to a more equitable distribution of resources and opportunities afforded by AI technologies. Advocates can push for policies that:

  • Protect workers’ rights
  • Promote initiatives aimed at enhancing human creativity
  • Foster social equity and economic justice

This collective effort may inspire a renewed focus on altruism and community welfare in the tech industry, aligning corporate strategies with the values that uphold human dignity.

The Ethical Imperative for Tech Corporations

Tech companies, too, must recognize their role in shaping a future that benefits humanity. Given the potential for AI to impact various aspects of life—from employment to cultural production—corporations must actively engage with ethical considerations in their development processes. Instead of merely pursuing profit, tech companies should prioritize responsible AI design that respects individual creativity and freedom.

By investing in community-centered projects and transparent operations, tech corporations can build trust and credibility, demonstrating their commitment to improving human welfare. Collaboration with creative professionals in enhancing AI tools—rather than replacing them—could foster a closer relationship between technology and the arts. Such partnerships may lead to innovative solutions to the challenges posed by emerging technologies while respecting the intrinsic value of human creativity.

Education as a Catalyst for Change

Considering the transformative potential of AI, educational institutions must take proactive steps in harnessing technology for empowerment. By integrating AI into curricula, educators can provide students with tools to navigate and critically evaluate the digital landscape while enhancing their intellectual and artistic capacities. This approach not only prepares students for future job markets but also nurtures a generation equipped with both technical skills and critical thinking.

Envision a future where AI is used to personalize education, offering tailored learning experiences that foster creativity and innovation. Such technological integration could mitigate educational disparities, providing equitable access to resources and knowledge for all students, irrespective of their backgrounds. This paradigm shift emphasizes the need for an education system that prioritizes human potential, centering on collaboration rather than competition.

The Intersection of Faith and Technology

The role of the Muslim community in shaping discourses around AI and human dignity cannot be overlooked. Drawing on Islamic principles that advocate justice, compassion, and communal welfare, Muslim scholars and leaders can guide conversations that frame technology as an instrument for enhancing human life rather than undermining it. By advocating for ethical technology and promoting a collective ethos rooted in human dignity, the Muslim community can contribute significantly to a future where AI aligns with the core values of society.

In this regard, the community’s engagement in dialogues about the ethical implications of AI can foster an understanding of technology as a tool that should be wielded responsibly. Such conversations may provide valuable insights into how we can approach AI in a way that serves humanity, ensuring that the voices of marginalized individuals are amplified and respected.

The Future of AI: Scenarios for Action

As we navigate the complexities of AI’s evolution, multiple scenarios present themselves, demanding thoughtful consideration and action:

  1. Technocratic Dystopia: If the current trajectory continues unchecked, we may find ourselves in a world where few tech corporations wield immense power over information, creativity, and personal freedoms. This scenario could foster authoritarian tendencies, leading to increased surveillance and the suppression of dissent.

  2. Empowerment through Collaboration: Alternatively, a more hopeful future envisions AI as a tool for human empowerment. Organizations and governments could prioritize ethical AI development, emphasizing its role in bolstering creativity and addressing social inequities.

  3. Grassroots Mobilization: The potential for grassroots movements to rise in response to AI’s impact signifies a turning point, wherein individuals come together to advocate for ethical standards and corporate accountability.

  4. Education as Transformative: If educational institutions embrace AI as a means to empower creativity and critical thinking, a new generation of thinkers and creators will emerge, equipped to navigate the complexities of a tech-centric world. This scenario could lead to cultural rejuvenation, with diverse narratives and artistic expressions flourishing in an environment that values human contributions.

Conclusion

The stakes surrounding AI’s evolution are immensely high, and its implications on our global society are profound. The confluence of technological advancement and ethical considerations underscores the necessity for proactive engagement from all stakeholders. As we collectively confront these unprecedented challenges, it is essential to remain attentive to the values that uphold our humanity, ensuring a future where technology serves humanity and enriches our dignity.

References

  • Alakwe, K. (2023). Human Dignity in the Era of Artificial Intelligence and Robotics: Issues and Prospects. Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Studies.
  • Hana, A. (2023). The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence: Examining the Ethical Considerations Surrounding the Development and Use of AI. American Journal of Technology.
  • Hofmann, J. R. (2021). Catholicism and Evolution: Polygenism and Original Sin (Part II). Scientia et Fides.
  • Okrah Oppong, E. (2025). Etyczne wyzwania sztucznej inteligencji w świetle nauczania Papieża Franciszka. Społeczeństwo.
  • Pagacz, M. (2022). Mathematics as a Way Towards the Creative Logos: Joseph Ratzinger/Benedict XVI’s Understanding of Scientificity. Collectanea Theologica.
  • Sadowski, R. F. (2021). The Role of Catholicism in Shaping a Culture of Sustainable Consumption. Religions.
  • Wach, K., Duong, C. D., Ejdys, J., Kazlauskaitė, R., Korzyński, P., Mazurek, G., Paliszkiewicz, J., & Ziemba, E. (2023). The dark side of generative artificial intelligence: A critical analysis of controversies and risks of ChatGPT. Entrepreneurial Business and Economics Review.
  • Zhang, J., & Zhang, Z. (2023). Ethics and governance of trustworthy medical artificial intelligence. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.
← Prev Next →